Comparative Analysis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words - 2

comparative degree Analysis - Essay ExamplePhilosophers like Peter Singer have adopted utilitarian viewpoints in order to justify a strongly favorable position to animal liberation and a honour for the environment. After all, it was Jeremy Bentham, John Stewart Mills family friend, who said of animals, the question is not can they reason, and not can they talk but can they suffer?John Stewart Mills piece constitution discusses the extent to which human beings can listen to and derive moral truths from constitution alone, and whether it is indeed a legitimate source for such information. Mill looks critically at claims made by philosophers throughout time and blank space that human action must conform to some underlying Law, a supreme ruler and crowning(prenominal) standard. He ultimately concludes that acting in accordance with any just natural laws is a material impossibility and therefore the concept itself an absurdity. The word nature, whatever it mode, does not confer an y prescriptive principle, whether it is endorsement or disapproval. Nature simply is what is, and not what ought to be. Nature, Mill writes, cannot be a proper stumper for us to imitate. Either it is right that we should kill because nature kills torture because nature tortures ruin and devastate because nature does the like or we ought not to consider what nature does, but what it is good to do (Mill, 2007).This passage encapsulates maybe what is most significant about Mills essay. Holmes Rolston, in earth Valuing the Natural Environment broaches this aforementioned(prenominal) topic by quoting Barry Commoners third law of ecology, which says Nature knows best (Rolston, Humans Valuing the Natural Environment, 1989, p. 32). This is the inversion of Mills thought that nature has no place in maneuver human action. It states simply because human beings value nature in some sense such means they ought to follow nature accordingly. Rolston